Quote Originally Posted by noddin0ff
I like to surf reviews, but I'm kind of tired of the one reviewer format. What I'd like to see is 3-5 short punchy bundled reviews from a regular pool of reviewers. That way the review is more like a discourse, you get a broader perspective, and you start to identify with the unique personalities of the reviewers. To me that identification is what makes readers come back for more.

2 cents.
Quote Originally Posted by MasterC
Not a bad idea.............perhaps place genre with expertise ?

For example :

Prog should be reviewed by Yech & Finch.
I find this concept much more favorable...especially if'n it means YECH is coming back

I'll not speak for Swishy, and clearly Jay is insane, but my perspective on a lot of popular music is extremely different than many if not most on the board. I'm actually finding the current "geneolgy-of-bands" threads interesting and informative. My understanding of rock music begins and ends on some days with Sisters of Mercy, Joy Division/New Order, krautrock/industrial, and the Rolling Stones, so I'm lacking a lot of the historical context for relevant commentary.

On the other hand, that doesn't in anyway mean I won't debate something I don't understand...