Quote Originally Posted by Chuck
Skeptic, I'm sorry to hear that you were so disappointed, but as we can see in the responses above, the articles actually generated some lively discussion. It's interesting that for once (is it the first time ever?) you and PCTower agree on something. Neither of you liked the articles very much.
Chuck - please stop putting words in my mouth. I thought the first article was good. I just questioned whether more work needed to be done. Is that an inappropriate question in engineering or science circles? If it is, I can't imagine how science ever progresses.

As to the second article, you are correct that I didn't particularly care for it, but I stated specific reasons - primarily that it seemed to contain a number of unqualified pronouncements backed up with little empirical or reasoned support. I also shared my recollection of the author's history.