Where are all the Dismemberment Plan fans???

[newtrix1]

The current tally for Slint vs. D-Plan is 2-1??? Wassupwitdat? I know there's at least 3-4 more D-Plan fans hiding in shadows....

vote here

Sorry for the little lobby, back to the regularly scheduled program...

[BarryL]

The current tally for Slint vs. D-Plan is 2-1??? Wassupwitdat? I know there's at least 3-4 more D-Plan fans hiding in shadows....

vote here

Sorry for the little lobby, back to the regularly scheduled program...

xxxxxxx

[-Jar-]

The current tally for Slint vs. D-Plan is 2-1??? Wassupwitdat? I know there's at least 3-4 more D-Plan fans hiding in shadows....

vote here

Sorry for the little lobby, back to the regularly scheduled program...

Very difficult to compare the two.

Different times, different situations.

Slint were peerless. They were there, did their business, and were gone in a flash. Their closest musical siblings were Bastro, B!tch Magnet, Codeine, and maybe Don Caballero. Who's really heard much about them? It's their musical children who really carried on and fleshed out many of the ideas (stop/start, soft/loud, speak/sing, etc..) that Slint touched on with their two albums. Gastr del Sol, Rodan, June of '44, Shipping News, Tortoise, Rachels, For Carnation... To me, it would make more sense to pit one of them, esp. June of '44 against the D-Plan.

I decided not to vote in this one. I just can't compare them.

-jar

[Slosh]

just not a fan of these stupid, annoying fucking polls

~Slosh - Hands up, who likes me?

[newtrix1]

just not a fan of these stupid, annoying fucking polls

~Slosh - Hands up, who likes me?

Of course you're entitled to an opinion, but I have no idea why any post that's music related and not personally offensve should elicit a comment like that.
FYI, in my opinion, your statement has far more negative impact to the board than any poll.
Don't mean to single you out, or publically chastize (oops guess I did both, sorry ) but hey, lighten up mon!

Just for that I'm gonna have to punish you with my latest comp! Btw, my mailbox hasn't received anything lately from one of my favorite compsters and neighbor to the north!

P.S. I still like you

[Slosh]

Of course you're entitled to an opinion, but I have no idea why any post that's music related and not personally offensve should illicit a comment like that.
FYI, in my opinion, your statement has far more negative impact to the board than any poll.
Don't mean to single you out, or publically chastize (oops guess I did both, sorry ) but hey, lighten up mon!

Just for that I'm gonna have to punish you with my latest comp! Btw, my mailbox hasn't received anything lately from one of my favorite compsters and neighbor to the north!

P.S. I still like you

Good thing we have all these polls, eh? Otherwise I wouldn't know what to listen to.

The who likes me thing was a Young Ones reference, BTW.

Uh, thanks for the comp, I think

~Slosh - fuck my impact

[mad rhetorik]

just not a fan of these stupid, annoying fucking polls

~Slosh - Hands up, who likes me?

Hey, nobody's being forced into participating. If people don't want me to poll anymore, I'll stop.

[Slosh]

Hey, nobody's being forced into participating. If people don't want me to poll anymore, I'll stop.

I guess if nobody isn't complaining...

Just one asshole's opinion. Do what you like. I'd hate to drive anyone away just because I sometimes think out loud. Pay no attention to me, ever!