Meddle is a great record...

[unleasHell]

I did not like horns back in the 70's, especially in rock / prog bands, in fact, I hated horns (sax, etc, althought flutes were cool) still don't care to much for horns today, as I recall Atom Heart Mother had a big horn section on it and I don't think I even have the LP anymore...

[3-LockBox]

althought flutes were cool

Well hell, you couldn't like prog at all if you didn't like flutes!

[unleasHell]

Well hell, you couldn't like prog at all if you didn't like flutes!

yeah or TULL...(LOL)

[Jim Clark]

freaky good call on that one Rae. I like Meddle an awful lot, although not my fave, it's in the top 2! Just last month I found a vinyl copy in reasonable shape for a couple of bucks. Have not cleaned it up yet, but I'll get around to it.

Years ago, a guy who was around for a short while offered to burn me a MFSL copy which was awesome. Sadly, the guy didn't know much about ripping and burning CDs so there were a bunch of skips throughout. Someday I'll get a clean copy of that too.

FWIW, Final Cut is my absolutely bestest most favoritest Pink Floyd of all time.

jc

[3-LockBox]

FWIW, Final Cut is my absolutely bestest most favoritest Pink Floyd of all time.

Really?

Its sounds so much like a Roger Waters album to me. It's OK, but it serves as a reminder of why Pink Floyd broke up. No way was this a band effort.

[ForeverAutumn]

FWIW, Final Cut is my absolutely bestest most favoritest Pink Floyd of all time.

jc

I'm a fan of this CD too. Although I know a lot of PF fans who don't like it for the reason that 3LB mentions. But if that's how you feel then you couldn't possibly like The Wall either. Gilmour has a few song credits on that disk, but its primarily Waters baby.

The Gunners Dream and The Fletcher Memorial Home are awesome songs.

[3-LockBox]

I'm a fan of this CD too. Although I know a lot of PF fans who don't like it for the reason that 3LB mentions. But if that's how you feel then you couldn't possibly like The Wall either. Gilmour has a few song credits on that disk, but its primarily Waters baby.

I used to be a fan of The Wall, but rarely listen to it anymore, and I rank it way down on the list of PF albums. I grew up on Floyd, since my older brother was a fan, there was always some PF being played. The Wall was my first sit down and listen album experience for Floyd, but as soon as I listened to DSOTM, The Wall took 2nd place, then third, then fourth, with each subsequent new album listen.