You grab two opinion pieces and declare that the future of 3D is not so bright?

Please tell me you are joking, because if not, then I have to conclude that you are not so bright as well.

People will vote with their feet. If the storytelling is compelling, and the 3D is well done, the masses will go in mass to see the movie. If it is junk(whether 3D or not) they will not support it. This goes for ANY film, 3D or not, and it has been that way since the beginning of film making. When the studios get burned financially, they will be more discerning about what will be work in 3D and what won't. No opinion pieces are going to change that dynamic. People will make up their own minds about 3D whether in the theater, or at home. What is NOT needed is anymore one sided posts featuring one sided opinions.

How you can say that Avatar and Up are the only 3D successes shows just how lightweight you are on this issue. Alice in Wonderland made $325 million in US box office alone, and a little over $500 million world wide. What an utter failure.

Clash of the Titans(horrible movie IMO) made $70 million in one week in the theaters, How to Train Your Dragon almost $100 million in two weeks in the theater. So far, total disasters at the box office.

Your opinion on anything film related is so twistedly stupid and moronic, my best advice to you is to just back away from it all together. This level of ignorance helps no one.

It is really to early to tell how well 3D will do in the home, there is not disc product on the market. Is it your habit to declare something either dead or unsucessful even before the products roll out is complete?