I was looking at the differences between the latest Roku and the Apple TV second generation, and decided yesterday on the WD TV Live Hub. I'm super happy with it. My problem with the Apple TV was that I couldn't get 1080p yesterday, plus the 2nd gen were all sold out. The Roku doesn't ship with the S/PDIF digital optical audio out, which is a bit lame. So the WD had everything I needed, and replaced my TiVo HD, without a service charge. Pretty nice.