Quote Originally Posted by E-Stat
Neither in my opinion. A troll is someone who intentionally drops a topical bomb, leaves, and expects controversy in the wake. While controversy can certainly be found in posts by either of them, I believe that was not their intention. Unfortunately, SVI is an easy target and doesn't understand why he triggers the kind of responses he gets. MW seems to be Rip Van Winkle incarnate having woken from a forty year sleep and likewise doesn't understand the responses he gets - albeit from a different perspective.
At first I agreed with this, but more and more as I read Melvin's posts I'm becoming convinced that his statements are intended to be contraversial....

SVI is probably just what he appears to be (slow), but I think Melvin is 100% Troll (he may well be a former audiophile, radio host and whatever else he claims to be... but I think his intentions are solely to stir up trouble)....