Here is the reason I think there should be a closed movie review section. First, if it is posted in fav films, as other topic come online the review tends to disappear onto the second page, third page etc. This makes it pretty difficult if a person was looking for a review of a particular movie. A central place, with the ability to alphabetize, or arrainge by genre is a much better option than scattering them all over the forum.

Secondly, it should be no problem for a person to read a review in the closed section, and then comment on it here. You don't even need to repost the review to do that. All you have to say is "regarding the review of x disc" and make your comments, and that should get the conversation going.

My main point is having a review only section keeps the reviews up front and center, keeps people from having to search for a title, and does not prevent one from commenting on the review. Of course what do I know, I eat chocolate covered ants for breakkie.