Quote Originally Posted by Geoffcin
A review, is a review. If you look in the consumer review section, everyone has a chance to speak his mind, but NOBODY can start a debate about someone elses review.

I'm glad that these reviews are sparking interest in the movie, but I think the real problem is that they are posted in a public forum rather than a closed topic. There's no other reviews pro, or consumer that are done that way on AR, or any other website that I can think of.
You know Geoff, you are absolutely right. Reviews should probably be in a closed forum, and debate on the review SHOULD take place here. I'll talk to Eric about it.