SACD produces analogue like sound?

[Dusty Chalk]

I don't appreciate your accusations of me lying. So much for civil, eh? I really don't see how you got to be a moderator. I've thrown a few digs in, myself, but they were meant to keep things light. Accusing me of lying when I was making one of my main points (and I was not lying) was just plain rude, and there was nothing light about it. Scumbag.

You keep claiming you're throwing facts around, when I'm trying to stress the differentiations when I'm talking personal opinion and personal experiences, and you're throwing around your personal experiences like they're facts. I don't care how important you are, how much experience you have, and how many times you've done something, your opinion never becomes fact.

This argument started because you made the statement: "Actually you cannot say the LP's clarity and range of sound will never be touched by CD on certain recordings." (Notice: CD, not SACD.) It is an opinion, and I stated mine to the contrary.

I'll get back to you later about some of your other points -- there's obviously at least one or two misunderstandings going on. The fact that I could hear the difference between 24/96 recorded vinyl and 16/44.1 recorded vinyl on the admittedly inferior (to dCS and EMM Labs) Masterlink should only prove even more that the difference is there. I wasn't talking about the different masters of I, Robot in which one could also hear the difference -- I probably shouldn't even have mentioned those, as it confused you (or you used them to act confused).