View Poll Results: Please vote for your more favorite between:

Voters
25. You may not vote on this poll
  • Lou Reed

    14 56.00%
  • Peter Gabriel

    11 44.00%
Results 1 to 20 of 20
  1. #1
    Forum Regular newtrix1's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Posts
    560

    March Music Madness: Lou Reed vs. Peter Gabriel

    Please consider the entire career of these 2 artists when voting (i.e. solo careers as well as period with V.U. & Genesis).

  2. #2
    Forum Regular Ex Lion Tamer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Location
    Ottawa
    Posts
    725
    As my daughter would say...
    "Puuuhhhleeeze"
    "I don't know. A proof is a proof. What kind of a proof? It's a proof. A proof is a proof, and when you have a good proof, it's because it's proven." The Right Honourable JC.

  3. #3
    Stone Stone's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2003
    Location
    Michigan
    Posts
    1,587
    I'd say it was a relatively close race for me until I read the part about factoring in their entire careers - then it became a landslide.
    And the world will turn to flowing pink vapor stew.

  4. #4
    Close 'n PlayŽ user Troy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Location
    Highway 6, between Tonopah and Ely
    Posts
    2,318
    Metal Machine Music.

    Puhleeeez is right!

  5. #5
    Forum Regular
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Location
    NYC
    Posts
    181
    Quote Originally Posted by newtrix1
    Please consider the entire career of these 2 artists when voting (i.e. solo careers as well as period with V.U. & Genesis).
    Another good matchup!

  6. #6
    Forum Regular newtrix1's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Posts
    560

    Fyi, here’s the status of the other matches:

    (as of Tues evening anyhow)

    Match 1: Nirvana (12) vs. Joy Division (10)

    Match 2: Beach Boys (13) vs. Doors (10)

    Match 3: Modest Mouse (9) vs. …and You Will Know us by the Trail of Dead (5)

    Match 4: REM (12) vs. XTC (7)

    Match 5: Miles Davis (10) vs. Jimi Hendrix (7)

    Match 6: Gomez (5) vs. Doves (7)

    Match 7: in progress

    Match 8: TBA

  7. #7
    Forum Regular newtrix1's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Posts
    560

    Rock & Roll Animal roolz, but...

    Quote Originally Posted by newtrix1
    Please consider the entire career of these 2 artists when voting (i.e. solo careers as well as period with V.U. & Genesis).
    Rock-n-Roll Animal is better than any single Peter Gabriel album, However PG's stuff has been (fairly) consistently good through his career.Otoh, LR's career is kind of like his collar on the cover of R&R Animal..."spikey". Overall, PG gets my vote for consistency, quality, and diversity.

  8. #8
    Forum Regular Ex Lion Tamer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Location
    Ottawa
    Posts
    725
    This one is way closer that I thought it would be and way closer than it should be in my opinion, so I am moved to offer an argument in favour of Lou Reed.

    Yes, Lou Reed's solo career is spotty, in comparison to Peter Gabriel's, but only because Lou took chances, while Peter Gabreil basically released the same album over and over again. Lou reed has 21 solo albums while P. Gabriel has what 7? 8? Some of Lous albums are bad, many are brilliant. I'd say Lou has more brilliant albums...(Transformer, Coney Island Baby, Berlin, Blue Mask, Street Hassle, New Sensations, New York, Songs for Drella), than Peter Gabriel has albums. Not to mention their respective influences on the R&R landscape. Lou Reed and the Velvets spawned an entire movement the reverberations of which is still being felt today. A list of bands influenced by the music of Lou Reed/Velvet Underground reads like a whos who of modern rock music. Literally 100s of bands, some marginal, many influential in there own right, are directly influenced by Lou Reed/Velvet Underground. Lou Reed, it could be argued is among the 5 most influential figures in rock and roll history. Peter Gabriel? Not in the conversation.

    Troy mentioned Metal Machine Music as some kind of proof of Lou Reed's marginal output. I'm not sure what Metal Machine Music is, but it's only one of 21 albums over a 35 year solo career, to judge his career on this one album is rediculous in the extreme. Puuuhhhleeeze indeed!

    This is an interesting match-up again Rick, but it really should be no contest.
    "I don't know. A proof is a proof. What kind of a proof? It's a proof. A proof is a proof, and when you have a good proof, it's because it's proven." The Right Honourable JC.

  9. #9
    Dubgazer -Jar-'s Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Location
    Cleveland, Ohio
    Posts
    942

    wow

    I voted for Lou, but I thought Peter would be destroying in the vote.

    Guess I'm wrong so far, unless the proggies haven't all voted yet.

    If being afraid is a crime we'll hang side-by-side,
    at the swingin' party down the line..


    The Replacements

  10. #10
    Loving This kexodusc's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Location
    Department of Heuristics and Research on Material Applications
    Posts
    9,025
    Hmmm....if Lou Reed was a bit more selective of the absolute junk filler that's made its way onto too many albums, I wouldn't think twice. Some musicians need "editors". This my chance to extract revenge for some the worst stuff I'll ever admit to paying money for...made especially painful because of the high potential for great music Reed has.
    That being said, I think Reed's got better stuff than Gabriel, and he deserves acknowledgment for this, too.
    I think both are close in their A material, with Reed having a bit more that I like...but Reed's "B" material is far worse, and more plentiful than Gabriel's.

    A sad way to determine a vote, but, this (jaded) customer is always right....PG gets mine.

  11. #11
    BooBs are elitist jerks shokhead's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Location
    So Cal
    Posts
    1,994
    Dont like either one.
    Look & Listen

  12. #12
    42 Regular
    Join Date
    Jan 2003
    Location
    West of the fields, long gone
    Posts
    1,338
    Yet another excellent matchup.

    I have to disagree with Ex Lion Tamer's take on this. It's not true that PG has been releasing the same album over and over. If you were to play Genesis' Trespass album, The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway, PG's first solo disc, and Up in succession, you would hardly think it was the same artist! And as for the quality vs. quantity debate...it's like Mozart vs. Beethoven. Two schools of thought there, but not a slam-dunk choice by any measure.

    For me and, I suspect, for others, the debate comes down to "more influential artist" vs. "music I enjoy somewhat more". And in the final analysis, I'm in agreement with those voting for Lou Reed. I listen to Gabriel more, but I rate them fairly closely on my own personal faves list. But in terms of influence, you're right. No contest there.

    Lou gets the vote. But it was a tough call.
    Last edited by Mr MidFi; 03-17-2005 at 09:37 AM.
    Mr. MidFi
    Master of the Obvious

  13. #13
    very clever with maracas Davey's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2004
    Location
    on some faraway beach...
    Posts
    2,916
    Not a very tough call for me even though I do love Peter Gabriel. Never much of a Genesis fan and my favorite is probably the one after he left, but those first few solo albums were the real stuff. I only listened to Peter Gabriel albums, though. I practically lived in some of those VU and Lou Reed albums. Could explore the songs for hours. Stuck in my head for days. Get rid of the Velvet Underground and probably a third to half of my record collection goes away too. Seems almost everything I listen to these days and for the last couple decades has a connection to VU or the Beatles.

  14. #14
    Forum Regular newtrix1's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Posts
    560

    don't mind the old Liontamer...

    Mark hasn't been well since the hockey season was cancelled. He needs to pull out a nice slab of heavy weight vinyl and let the bass notes of Tony Levins chapman stick on something like "I Don't Remember" wash over him for a few minutes. Then he'll come around.

  15. #15
    Can a crooner get a gig? dean_martin's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2002
    Location
    Lower AL
    Posts
    2,838
    Quote Originally Posted by newtrix1
    Please consider the entire career of these 2 artists when voting (i.e. solo careers as well as period with V.U. & Genesis).
    Have to go with Lou Reed/VU on this one. I discovered Reed's and VU's music in depth at a critical stage in my life.

    I've really only paid attention to Gabriel's singles and some of those I didn't care for, but I've been curious about his first 3 albums of late and will probably check them out.

  16. #16
    Forum Regular
    Join Date
    May 2002
    Location
    Lawrenceville
    Posts
    1,112
    Duh!

    PG all the way.

  17. #17
    Crackhead Extraordinaire Dusty Chalk's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Location
    below the noise floor
    Posts
    3,636
    Quote Originally Posted by Ex Lion Tamer
    ...while Peter Gabreil basically released the same album over and over again...
    This is so wrong. I really don't hear the comparison even between his first three albums -- the first one was audibly an album from a Genesis alumnus, the second one was a right turn into Fripp's and Eno's domains (not Fripp&Eno, though), and the third one is where he truly found his own "voice". And I really can't see how anyone who heard So and Security could say they were in any way similar.

    And don't even get me started on Passion or Long Walk Home.

    My vote goes to PG.
    Eschew fascism.
    Truth Will Out.
    Quote Originally Posted by stevef22
    you guys are crackheads.
    I remain,
    Peter aka Dusty Chalk

  18. #18
    Global Village Idiot mad rhetorik's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2002
    Location
    Cortland NY
    Posts
    444

    Lightbulb

    Even with a spotty solo career, Lou over Peter anyday. His participation in The V.U. alone puts him over the top easily. Then you've got Transformer and Berlin, both superb (Rock 'N' Roll Animal, though acclaimed, never did much for me... revisioning VU standards as stadium-rock anthems was kind of a questionable move).

    I never did get into Genesis much, and I have little experience with Gabriel's solo work outside of So (which never set me afire anyway).
    "...and then at the end of the letter I like to write <i>'P.S. - this is what part of the alphabet would look like if Q and R were eliminated.'</i> "


    <b>_R.I.P. Mitch Hedburg 1968-2005_</b>

  19. #19
    Forum Regular edtyct's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2002
    Posts
    1,370
    I loved VU but wasn't wild about everything of LRs afterward, but I've always liked PG's work, even more solo than with Genesis. My feeling, however, is that the solo LR and PG aren't really comparable. I think of PG as more of a composer with a different sort of musical/lyrical agenda than LR. Something like the music from Last Temptation of Christ, Birdy, and the OVO Millennium Show aren't really what LR is all about.

    So far as influence goes, PG's early and continuing involvement in World Music through WOMAD and Real World has had a big impact, and his early adoption of technologies to encourage more people to take an active role in making music flew in the face of purists but in the end was on the winning side. Witness the popularity of the drum machine and the ubiquitous synth (the worst effects of which probably weren't what PG had in mind). But I think it's true that he doesn't pave the kind of personal road that allows people to follow in his footsteps very readily or identifiably. LR does.

    LR seemed to follow Andy Warhol's prescription of plugging away constantly and letting it all hang out (maybe not always to his best advantage). PG has a far more deliberate way of working, allowing for far less output. He seems to have more of an auteur/audiophile sensibility than LR. They just seem to be coming from different places.

    Ed

  20. #20
    Forum Regular thepogue's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Location
    Hayes, Va
    Posts
    490

    I'm goin wiff Lou...

    I think it's a timing issue with me...hear Lou for the first time in a new way club in '81...great stuff...but kinda off his rocker..

    Peace, Pogue
    • Mark Levinson No. 27
    • Musical Fidelity 308cr
    • Martin Logan Prodigy's
    • Ariel Acoustics 10-T
    • Rega Planet CD
    • CJ Premier 9 DAC
    • Linn LP12 - Basik Plus - Valhalla
    • Benz Micro Cart.
    • Akai GX 747 Reel to Reel
    • Straight Wire Virtuoso Interconnects

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads

  1. March Music Madness: AC/DC vs. Talking Heads
    By newtrix1 in forum Rave Recordings
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: 04-03-2004, 02:25 PM
  2. March Music Madness: Yes vs. Wilco
    By newtrix1 in forum Rave Recordings
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: 04-02-2004, 06:47 PM
  3. March Music Madness: AC/DC vs. Prince
    By newtrix1 in forum Rave Recordings
    Replies: 10
    Last Post: 03-30-2004, 10:35 AM
  4. March Music Madness: Yes vs. Fleetwood Mac
    By newtrix1 in forum Rave Recordings
    Replies: 11
    Last Post: 03-26-2004, 10:52 AM
  5. To Hell In A Hand Basket
    By BarryL in forum Rave Recordings
    Replies: 61
    Last Post: 12-17-2003, 08:30 AM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •