Hey Wooch,

I just ditched my Audi A4 recently and picked up a Buick La Crosse. Here are some links you might be able to utilize in trying to make your decision:
Japanese cars voted most reliable by huge margin in Consumer Reports survey - NY Daily News

Used Cars, New Cars, Reviews, Photos and Opinions - CarGurus

Based on your original list my first favorable reaction was for the Honda Fit/Civic.