What do I need to know about a DVR?

[kpzbee]

I'm think of getting a digital video recorder since my VCR is dieing. I'm spoiled from watching DVDs on my big screen. Tapes look like heck on it! Whats important to know about them? I don't want a TiVo or have to pay a subscription to anything.

[Slosh]

Well, it depends. If you have cable get a Tivo. I believe they can be used in their "basic" mode without a subscription. If you have Dish or DirecTV you're better off getting a receiver with the DVR onboard because you'll be recording the signal digitally with no loss of picture quality whatsoever and if a program is in DD 5.1, you'll get that too. I'm not sure if any HD DVRs are on the market yet.

I have the Dish Network 508 and have had no problems with it so far (two+ years).

[eisforelectronic]

Scientific Atlanta, who provides 90% of cable boxes, has a HD DVR. HD recording has a capacity of 20 hrs, SD is up to 120 hrs. 160 Gb hard drive vs. 80 Gb in their regular Explorer 8000.

[hershon]

Can you make external DVD or VHS copies off your Time Warner HD DVR rental? Right now I can't because for some bizarre reason the folks at Timer Warner in LA have no currently programmed that feature into the DVR. Is there a way to get around this that actually works?

Scientific Atlanta, who provides 90% of cable boxes, has a HD DVR. HD recording has a capacity of 20 hrs, SD is up to 120 hrs. 160 Gb hard drive vs. 80 Gb in their regular Explorer 8000.

[eisforelectronic]

Can you make external DVD or VHS copies off your Time Warner HD DVR rental? Right now I can't because for some bizarre reason the folks at Timer Warner in LA have no currently programmed that feature into the DVR. Is there a way to get around this that actually works?

Things are a little different on the HD DVR from the standard DVR. On the standard one, in order to get the Aux out to activate you have to turn on the pip feature. So you go to your list find what you want and start it, turn on pip, and then swap it.

On the HD DVR it is possible that the other outputs besides the component out may not be activated at all. Some of these do not even have a functioning coax output. Also some of the boxes use the green video out to double as the composite video out.

Does your DVI output work? Again some of them do and some of them don't. the DVI feature is not an officially supported feature either.

[hershon]

Right now I'm not using any DVI output whatever that is. I tried doing several things to try to make video copies from the HD DVR and nothing worked, I even tried to make a copy from the monitor out on my TV to the VCR and that didn't work either. Why Time Warner isn't making the "aux out" feature available right now I don't understand.

Other than that I'm happy with the HD DVR. I'm pretty sure you have the same model, you can record 40 hours standard or 20 hours HD. For some reason, this model number got crappy reviews on the internet (which didn't have anything to do with the "auxillary" not being activated. I don't understand their complaining, the HD picture and sound is great.
I just wish there was a way to record on it to skip commercials. According to TimeWarner there isn't. I was originally thinking of trying to buy one of these DVR's outright but found out if I did I'd just be throwing out money because Time Warner would still charge $10 a month for DVR service with or without their rental.

Things are a little different on the HD DVR from the standard DVR. On the standard one, in order to get the Aux out to activate you have to turn on the pip feature. So you go to your list find what you want and start it, turn on pip, and then swap it.

On the HD DVR it is possible that the other outputs besides the component out may not be activated at all. Some of these do not even have a functioning coax output. Also some of the boxes use the green video out to double as the composite video out.

Does your DVI output work? Again some of them do and some of them don't. the DVI feature is not an officially supported feature either.

[kpzbee]

Well, it depends. If you have cable get a Tivo. I believe they can be used in their "basic" mode without a subscription. If you have Dish or DirecTV you're better off getting a receiver with the DVR onboard because you'll be recording the signal digitally with no loss of picture quality whatsoever and if a program is in DD 5.1, you'll get that too. I'm not sure if any HD DVRs are on the market yet.

I have the Dish Network 508 and have had no problems with it so far (two+ years).

I have cable & don't want to pay for Tivo. The cable costs enough. I was wondering how the difference was beween having a hard drive or not having one. I don't have a cable box at all.

[PDL63]

kpzbee,

I notice you own a Pioneer DVR-520H. I just bought one and now notice that it emits a rather distracting hum after being on a while. I'm not sure but I think it might have something to do with the fan that cools the hard drive? Anyway, I just wondered if your unit is quiet or if it is emitting any distracting noises, and if so, how you dealt with them. Thanks! PDL

[hershon]

I can't speak for direct TV but if you have Cable service such as Time Warner, you can't just hook up a DVR to your cable/system, they charge $10 for DVR service whether you rent one from them or not and there's no additional charge for the rent. I'm renting an HD DVR from them, that was listed above and I'm very happy with it. Unlike Tivo you don't need a seperate phone line.

I have cable & don't want to pay for Tivo. The cable costs enough. I was wondering how the difference was beween having a hard drive or not having one. I don't have a cable box at all.

[kpzbee]

I can't speak for direct TV but if you have Cable service such as Time Warner, you can't just hook up a DVR to your cable/system, they charge $10 for DVR service whether you rent one from them or not and there's no additional charge for the rent. I'm renting an HD DVR from them, that was listed above and I'm very happy with it. Unlike Tivo you don't need a seperate phone line.

But where I live, I don't pay ANY extra for having a DVR. I use it all the time with basic cable. Sorry your cable system is a rip.

PDL63, I think your correct about the cooling fan. I have mine in a a/v cabinet & sit back from it about 10', so I don't/can't hear it. The 510's were noted for a noisy H/D but that was fixed in the 520 from what I've read.

[hershon]

Out of curiosity, where do you live, who is the company and in regards to your DVR can you: 1. Record shows straight off the cable on screen guide- for instance you see a show you want to record and all you need to do is click the record button & 2. If you can do that, can you also do the same on digital and premiere channels like BBC America, Trio, Sci Fi, HBO & Showtime for example? I seriously doubt you can but if you can do so, more power to you. I'm on Time Warner in Los Angeles.

But where I live, I don't pay ANY extra for having a DVR. I use it all the time with basic cable. Sorry your cable system is a rip.

PDL63, I think your correct about the cooling fan. I have mine in a a/v cabinet & sit back from it about 10', so I don't/can't hear it. The 510's were noted for a noisy H/D but that was fixed in the 520 from what I've read.

[IsmaVA]

I have cable & don't want to pay for Tivo. The cable costs enough. I was wondering how the difference was beween having a hard drive or not having one. I don't have a cable box at all.

How much are you paying for cable?

In my experience a DSS service WITH a PVR is cheaper than hwat you would pay for basic cable . . .