Quote Originally Posted by ForeverAutumn
Holy crap my head is spinning. Adam and Eve go back to Season one. So they really did have the story planned out from the beginning.

So, was that Locke with Jack and Kate in the cave or was it really Smokey?
Locke. Remember Benry had to kill him (strangle). Smokey took over the body when it was returned in the casket on the beach. In my opinion.

Great story.