From the polarized opinions of Fargo and Napoleon Dynamite, I'm going to guess that there are equally polarized views on humor. I thought both where very funny, in the same way that Pulp Fiction was funny - although we did get some stares from people walking out of the theater on that one (this is Orange County, after all).

I also thought Donny Darko was very good, although I agree that Jack Black fares better in dramas than comedies. What was that one where he invented some kind of spray to vaporize dog poop and became a millionaire? That was two hours of my life I'd like to get back.

Speaking of dramas, NCFOM and There will be Blood where very good films. Those wheren't so much about the storyline or the action scenes, but about the character development. Daniel Lewis is an excellent actor, IMO.