As someone who was once a 17-yr-old girl (although at 17 I would have totally dismissed this band in favour of Iron Maiden), I feel qualified to start this thread over.

I bought this disk on Wednesday. But before I could open it I was graced with a download. So I've been spinning the d/l and not really digging it too much. I'm debating taking the CD back. I haven't quite made up my mind though.

I loved Transatlanticism and Plans, but this one just isn't clicking with me.