What DVD recorder would you choose?

[stereonewbie]

http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg...&s=electronics

http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg...&s=electronics


Panasonic w/VCR

or

Phillips

[hershon]

Here is a quick lession that I picked up on this forum, if I am wrong on anything I'm saying,
please someone correct:

1. If you are planning to copy commercial DVD's, you can not copy them on these stand alone recorders because it is hurting people like Brad Pitt's $15 million salary. Just kidding! But seriously, the only way to copy commercial DVD's (almost all of which are encrypted) is through a DVD burner either built in your computer or an external recorder which you can attach by USB and a free software program called DVD Shrink (there are several others as well). A program like DVD shrink decrypts the DVD. These type programs are not commercially sold no matter how "DVD recorder software misleads you to think you can do this with their stuff-you can't in reality". Again its easy to use and free on the internet. Therefore if you are planning to copy a commercial DVD do not buy a stand alone DVD burner but one that you can either attach internally or externally to your computer. You can believe it or not get an excellent new sealed DVD recorder for your computer, internal or external from between $80-$140 on Ebay (Buy it now feature as well).

2. Secondly, DVD standalone recorders do not record in 5.1 surround sound but DVD internal or external recorders for your computer, does.

[stereonewbie]

But can I record programs off of tv from my PC with it?

[sy_lu]

But can I record programs off of tv from my PC with it?

Yes, if you get a TV tuner card or external TV USB box. You can also get a cheaper video capture card/box but you need to feed your TV video out to it and loose the ability to do timer porgram recording.

[kpzbee]

But can I record programs off of tv from my PC with it?

Yes you can record off of a TV just like a VCR. I bought a Pioneer DVR 520H (80gb hd)about a month ago. I love it. I wanted to replace my VCR with it. Way better IMO, to watch a recorded TV show on my 57" screen.
As for making a backup of your DVD collection, yes it can be done with an Video Stabilizer. I'm not sure that it will copy the 5.1 soundtrack. I haven't got that far into it yet. There is a lot of info at this site AVS forum I'd suggest doing some reading up before you buy. As I said, I love mine for what I use it for.

[hershon]

Hi, I'm renting for $10 a month an HD DVR from Time Warner Cable that works great and doesn't require a phone line. In regards to your DVR, do you have to still pay the cable people for this (unless you have Direct TV) and will it still work with your cable box even if you're not paying the cable people for it? How much did yours cost? Thanks

Yes you can record off of a TV just like a VCR. I bought a Pioneer DVR 520H (80gb hd)about a month ago. I love it. I wanted to replace my VCR with it. Way better IMO, to watch a recorded TV show on my 57" screen.
As for making a backup of your DVD collection, yes it can be done with an Video Stabilizer. I'm not sure that it will copy the 5.1 soundtrack. I haven't got that far into it yet. There is a lot of info at this site AVS forum I'd suggest doing some reading up before you buy. As I said, I love mine for what I use it for.

[kpzbee]

No, I don't pay anything since it has no Tivo. I didn't want to pay any subscription with one. I don't have a cable box but it will work with it if I do get one. I found it on sale for $449. You can get cheaper ones without the hard drive. I didn't want to have to record to a media (like a VCR) just to record a TV program. I just record to the HDD, watch it later & hit the delete button afterwards. It's just that simple! Basicly, I bought it replace my VCR but it will do a lot of other stuff.

If your interested, you can to to Pioneer's website & look it up. If you register, you can d/l the owners manual for it & read it. This way you'll have a perfect feel for what it will do.