I would like to put my .02$ on this topic. Although American Idol may not be your cup of tea, it is perfect for family viewing. I know full well that I can sit comfortably and watch an hour with my 3 girls 5,7,9 and not have to worry about profanity, sex, or violence. I do not shelter my kids, but also I am careful as to what they watch.

America's funniest videos is also another family favorite.

However, on the filp side my wife and I enjoy 24, and Lost. Neither one would be good for family viewing (for those with small children).

So don't begrudge a show that allows people to watch with their kids. We enjoy it, and it livens up the dinner discussion. If you don't want to watch it, dont.