Overplayer / Underplayer

[Hyfi]

I have been wanting to make this comp ever since we talked about Bass players last year. My list was deemed all Overplayers by Swish. Dusty then asked if all the others are Underplayers. These two words stuck in my head. There are lots of good bass players who get little or no credit while there are others we all know. Some of these tracks my be real familiar, but most are from my own collection.

One of the greatest Underplayers in MHO would be Greg Lake. He has one of the most beautiful and emotional voices for a guy. Another bassist/vocalist I like is James Dewar from Robin Trower fame. His voice is also captivating while his bass playing is not overdone.

There are also those players that we mainly hear as Overplayers but still have tracks as Underplayers. Stanley Clarke would be one of the main guys here. Others would be Tony Levin, Jon Camp(Renaissance), Chris Squire, and Mark Egan. Other guys just cant seem to go any slower than a mile a minute. Jeff Berlin(Bruford) is one as well as Stuart Hamm, and Michael Manring (although he is calm on Michael Hedges recordings).

This is a collection of some of my favorite tunes or artists featuring great bass. I tried to find as many of the "Overplayers" underplaying as to shed some light on their slower tasteful music. Some are not well known at all like Jimmy Charleson(Carl Filipiak Band), Martin Dresdin(Focus) and Craig Herlihy(YokeShire).

The hardest thing about making this comp is trying to figure out a good sequence. I settled on starting out slow with some Underplaying and working my way through the Overplaying. The comp ends with an overplayer underplaying on a track with nothing but bass.

Here's the play list if anyone is interested:

Jaco- Pat Metheny- Mark Egan
Lisa- Stanley Clarke- Stanley Clarke
Focus II- Focus- Martin Dresdin
Little Girl- Robin Trower- Rustee Allen(bass)- James Dewar(vocals)
It Hurts- Greg Lake- Greg Lake
Nature Boy- Annie Haslam- Jon Camp
Heartbeat- King Crimson- Tony Levin
America- Yes- Chris Squire
Flyin’ East - Fourplay- Nathan East
Blue Entrance- Carl Filipiak- Jimmy Charleson
Egocentric Molecules - Jean-Luc Ponty- Ralphe Armstrong
Call of the Wild- Stuart Hamm- Stuart Hamm
Cruel & Unusual- Michael Manring- Michael Manring
Sample & Hold- Bruford- Jeff Berlin
Shape of a Dancer- YokeShire- Craig Herlihy
Just My Wish- Carl Filipiak- Jimmy Charleson

[BarryL]

I have been wanting to make this comp ever since we talked about Bass players last year.




One of the all time underrated bass players, I agree, is Jon Camp from Renaissance. While he doesn't pack quite the punch as Chris Squire, he is equally melodic throughout his '70s recordings.

If you're offering up, I'd be a happy camper!

[Dusty Chalk]

One of the greatest Underplayers in MHO would be Greg Lake. Just being pedantic -- have you heard Pictures at an Exhibition lately? I totally disagree with the terminology of "overplaying" vs. "underplaying" (I was just making fun of the term when I asked if Jay was an underplayer, since "overplaying" is his pet peeve), but that would definitely not qualify as underplaying. Love that one moment with the wah-wah -- one of my favourite bass moments ever, and preceded Cliff Burton by quite a few years.

[Chip_B]

Jaco- Pat Metheny- Mark Egan
Lisa- Stanley Clarke- Stanley Clarke
Focus II- Focus- Martin Dresdin
Little Girl- Robin Trower- James Dewar
It Hurts- Greg Lake- Greg Lake
Nature Boy- Annie Haslam- Jon Camp
Heartbeat- King Crimson- Tony Levin
America- Yes- Chris Squire
Flyin’ East - Fourplay- Nathan East
Blue Entrance- Carl Filipiak- Jimmy Charleson
Egocentric Molecules - Jean-Luc Ponty- Ralphe Armstrong
Call of the Wild- Stuart Hamm- Stuart Hamm
Cruel & Unusual- Michael Manring- Michael Manring
Sample & Hold- Bruford- Jeff Berlin
Shape of a Dancer- YokeShire- Craig Herlihy
Just My Wish- Carl Filipiak- Jimmy Charleson
Just a small point, but Rustee Allen plays bass on 'Little Girl'. On the album 'In City Dreams', Dewar just does vocals. I think the same is true of 'Caravan to Midnight' (Allen on bass, Dewar on vocals)

[ForeverAutumn]

Hit me.

And please don't rely on Barry to make a copy for me. We all know how that'll turn out. ;)

I never did get that acoustic stuff you sent him way back when.

[Finch Platte]

I'd love to hear a copy of this, please. I've got a friend who would like it, too- I'll burn him a copy, if you'd send me one.

Thanks!

fp

[Hyfi]

Just a small point, but Rustee Allen plays bass on 'Little Girl'. On the album 'In City Dreams', Dewar just does vocals. I think the same is true of 'Caravan to Midnight' (Allen on bass, Dewar on vocals)


I missed the fine print there. Rustee ain't bad either.

[Hyfi]

Hit me.

And please don't rely on Barry to make a copy for me. We all know how that'll turn out. ;)

I never did get that acoustic stuff you sent him way back when.


Can I trust you will give Barry his copy if I send you 2? Canadian postage is a killer for the unemployed!

I will try and remember what acoustic stuff I sent you. I think it was Craig Chaquico & Acoustic Alchemy.

PS: I never got the 70's set he asked me if I would like one a year ago.....hehehe

[BarryL]

Can I trust you will give Barry his copy if I send you 2?

PS: I never got the 70's set he asked me if I would like one a year ago.....hehehe

Oh yeah. I have no independent recollection.

It's not that I don't make the comps, it's that I don't send them out! I have yours sitting right here. But I have to package it and get it to the post office. (Didn't I say I'd try to do it by Christmas. I usually make that a standard part of the deal.)

My real excuse is that I've been away on business most of the summer and I'm still busy as heck. I know, it's a lousy excuse.

As to the accoustic comps for FA, I promise to do them for her (but don't tell her that I promised).

[Hyfi]

Just being pedantic -- have you heard Pictures at an Exhibition lately? I totally disagree with the terminology of "overplaying" vs. "underplaying" (I was just making fun of the term when I asked if Jay was an underplayer, since "overplaying" is his pet peeve), but that would definitely not qualify as underplaying. Love that one moment with the wah-wah -- one of my favourite bass moments ever, and preceded Cliff Burton by quite a few years.

I knew my memory was a little off and that you would correct me when you saw it. Either way your comments helped me come up with a decent bass comp since I never finished one I started 2 years ago called "BassBalls".

I guess to me anything but Lead Bass is underplaying!

[ForeverAutumn]

Can I trust you will give Barry his copy if I send you 2? Canadian postage is a killer for the unemployed!

I will try and remember what acoustic stuff I sent you. I think it was Craig Chaquico & Acoustic Alchemy.

PS: I never got the 70's set he asked me if I would like one a year ago.....hehehe

I'm just busting Barry's chops. My position in life obligates me to do so. :D

You can send both copy's to him. I'm sure that I'll get mine......or else!