Help with new center channel buy

[jjp735i]

I want to upgrade my center channel. RIght now I'm using an 14 year old onkyo that sounds dull to me. All my other speakers are yamaha. The front 2 are Yamaha NS-836 with upgraded crossovers and tweeters. I like that the Onkyo can be set upside down so that angles upwards, seems to bring the voices right onto the screen.

I was looking at Polk centers just because it can also be placed upside down and angles up. Are there any others I should look at, would like to stay around $300.oo or under.
I was looking at this one, I know at litte more, but that is ok.

Polk Audio - TSi Series Loudspeakers (http://www.polkaudio.com/homeaudio/tsi/index.php?s=cs20)

Thanks, jjp

[recoveryone]

Why not look at the same series of Yammys to keep the same spec's as your fronts or the NS-444

http://forums.audioreview.com/ UXGyYfFxkjGRUUHy8gIycpLCwsFx4xNTAqNSYrLikBCQoKDgwO FA8PGikYGBgpKSkpKSkpKSkpKSkpKSksKSkpKSkpKSkpKSkpKS ksLCksKSkpLCwsLCkpKSksKSkpKf/AABEIAOEA4QMBIgACEQEDEQH/xAAcAAEAAgIDAQAAAAAAAAAAAAAABAcFBgECAwj/xABGEAABAwIBBwkDCgQFBQEAAAABAAIDBBEhBQYHEjFBcRMiMl FhgZGhsUJSchQjM0NigpKywdEVJKLwJURTc8IIg7PS4aP/xAAYAQEBAQEBAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAQIEA//EABwRAQEBAAMBAQEAAAAAAAAAAAABEQIDEiExBP/aAAwDAQACEQMRAD8AvFERAREQEREBERAREQEREBERAREQEREBE RAREQEREBERAREQEREBERAREQEREBERAREQEREBERAREQEREBE RAREQEREBERAREQEREBERAREQEREBERAREQEREBERAREQEREBE RARFxdByiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIuLoOUXF11fMBtIHEgeqDuix1 RnDTR9OohbxkYP1WMqNIlAzbVRn4dZ3oEGyItKn0t0LdjpHcIz +pCx82maH2KeU/E5rf3VxNWLdLqq5tMch6FMwfE9zvQBQptK1W7oiJnBhd6lMpq4 EuqSlz/AK1315HwtY39FElzkqX9KolP33DyBV8p6Xs6UDaQOJsok2XIG9 KeIffb+6ot1U47XE8ST6o16eT0uabPSkb9e0/CHO9Aoc2kOmGzlHcGW/MQqqbIu7Xq+U9LGl0lx+zC88XNHpdRJNJL/ZhYOLnH0AWkBy5D08m1tcmf9SdnJt4MJ9SVGkzvqnfXEcA0egW AD1zyiYaycuWp39KaQ/fcPQr2pM5KiPozOsNzuePB11h9dNdMNbrQ6Q3jCWIO7WHVPgbh bHk/OunlwEga4+y/mHzwPcVVGsmupi6u4OXKqDJ2ck8HQedX3Xc5p7js7rLbck6SIX WbPaI+9cFnfvb3qYsrckUX+Ix/6jPxN/dFFaBnLprhpamSnFPK98Ti1x1msaSNtr3JHateqP8AqAkP0dIw dWtI4+gC07S0LZUqSdoeLcDHGbcFqMclxh3jeP3HaqzdWbPpyr ndFsDODHO/M5Y2fSvlF/8AmdX4WMb6BaMJV6CRVNrYqjPKsk6dXOf+44eigSV73dKR7vic 53qVj+UXYPV+CYHr0bKoTZF3D0RNbMvUSqAJF6NlQT2zL1Eyxv ygdfmvWN5OwE8AT6KjItlXq2VRY6SUi/Jvt2i1/Gy9xRvG3Vbxe3DwupokNlXoJFDAaOlKwcNZxPkFwayMDpuJ7Gg DzKumMiJF6NlWGfleMbGvPF9r/hC8H5xEXtGwdV7v9Spq42QTDrXYTj+8VpsucUtrAgcGtH6KHUZ Yldtkd4lNG/uqQMDhxw9VEly9E3a9v4m/uq5lnJ2m/mvF0qaLAlzyhb7QPDWJ/KoUuf8AGDg1x7repXGaOiesrwHkCGE+3IDdw62s2njgFY1HoAo mD5+eZ5+JsQ7hZTVxVk2kJ3sx+bR+hUGbP2c7AB3u9L28lbmUv +n6jkafk88rDuu5srb9u9VRnlo3qsnG8jQ+K+ErOj94bWlRWNm ztqHe2BwaFEkyzM695X4g3sbbduxQlk8s5aFQyEcjGx0TC172i xmJJIc/dcCwUVfHIN93zP7ovSyIK90yR/4nU9pjP/4xqtWSlp/vy6laOl0XylUcY/8AxRqrp2WKqRLiqwTjt8D/APVJF92PDb4bVhl7wSnWaL7x6ppjPw5Mmdshk/CR6qUzN+c+w1vxPaPIErYZpw3FzrC4GJ68AEfhgf1/Vaxhh2Zsye1JGOGs63kFIjzdYDzpyfhYB6kqYXrLZDzcmqjzBZ vvHZ3daKwbcjwAY8o49rreQA9V6ilhba0LT8Rc71KtSh0dUsLd aofrdZc7k2+AI9VKbRZH6P8AK9XSv53UXFSNqw0nVYxvBjR+i6 Pym+1tY92Ctqt0a0VQy8DtQ7ixwe3wv+qrDOvNGahfaQXY7ovF y13ZfcewoYxctWTtJ8VHdOo75F5ukVZe75lHfMuhdc2G07BtJ7 lnMm5hV1RYx0zw0+1JaJvi+x8k1WvvmUd8ysil0IVTrcpPAzrA L5CPAW81NGgTrrR3Qn9XqLipHSrwklVuTaAHezWt74XD0cVo+e mjioyfG2V74pI3O1NeMk6r8SA4EAgkA+CGNTfIrc0R6OI32q6z VsBrxxOtg3aJJAd28A8VoujjNf5fXxxuHzbefJ8Ld3ebDxV95a hi5YtY0NDGtExHtuAGqzgGtbfgOpSmJFdnC+TCA8lFsD7c94+w 04Nb2lYSZsZN3DlDvMjnPP7LrPVXK8C665+XfJcjq4/z2za9WRRg6zA6J3vxPc0jiNh8FPkyk+Vgp6gRyiUhrJHCzZW+1 HINjX27isI8kG4wUiIiRuo7Br8MPYkGLXDqN7Fe3Hl6jw58fNV FpIzKOT6otb9FJcxnq62d1/BaiFf+kCi+W5HL3ActBra3+5CSHW4i/iqAC1WX058mRZf5KUWVVNpUZfKNT8Tf/GxVpWQYq1dJMV6+p+MfkYq7q6dbYYAtXemHPb8TfUKTLBiukEV nt+JvqFMa1YU4BuCLi/nfBd6/KL5X68hu6zRsDRZos0ADsUaWTFdqKnMsjWDecewbz/fWFthms2Mh/KJRrdHCw97G2z3b4dtlv78qag5Gk1ebzZJiNZrCNrY2+24fhHa oEuTmxRxRMaBK5t3OG2GHECx3ON3AHaBrdaPIY0NaAGtwAGxef Pl5n16cOF5XI6yU7L60l5X+/Kdc9wODe4IagbLNt8IsvB84XRz7rnndddF6JI9Yg1rtaMmB+58 eAJ+2zY4dyzNJKa6QwVbhhHZ0YHMnFz87GdxuW9rS3tWtOktw3 he7Z3ABzPpITysR3kDFzOBbcW67Lol1zWearrPDID6GqfC4kgc 6N3vxnonjhY9oXvmRm7HVySuqHuZDAwPk1Ok4udqsa3A4k33E7 htW+6Y6JtRQQ1bNrC3HrjlsPJ2qsNoOYHurWuAIMcAIOII1pVp G55MdQUbAaeABxG3VvJ96RxPkVxU54yO6DWt488+a6ZWNpSN2G HYsFleR5AipjEamX6JkjwzWAID3NBwcWg3thgCcbWNzDU+bLsz tsruAw9FxG+V3tv73O/dRn5iVFJaaTKIlLQ+SWLk+nDG28ghaXc4jm7ht3bFkxLcYW7bY 4jbbvSfSu1MHawBlk6sHFtuBWC0t5NbDkTVbe3yiEn8Lx6ALYI BzhxWJ00n/AAgf78Po9LEjH6B8nNho56twxcXW+CIbPxErP1DzqC55z7veet zsT/fYomYzdTN9lsNZmP35sfVTa8YjgvHsucXt1TeUa+S+ondEx5Yx gHKOAu4l2LWtvswxupxyY+AgFznNdhz7Eg2uDfqKhUEpgqJNZp LJC1wcATZzRqkG3csplWvdNbbYb9i5bmOuevSPMV0onYO7j3g//VHfIVKyZHcOPBo8bldHTPjn779ZSJmtFWxnFrix1v8AciAd6L5 rtivop9ZqU9dKbWBDR28lFj53XzqzavavCPsGyLvqLhRVWZ/wXrag/b/4NVf1tMrNz4i/m5/jH5WrQq+JbjDWZIVGjZzhxHqsrNHioWpiOI9VBsMki27Rxk3lJ S87AQ0HqA5zvUeC0h8mKszMNupQOeMCY53X7bvAPkPBUjLRTco ZJv8AUdzeyMc1g/CAsPlzKXIxl1rnANG9znGzQOJKzUMdoWDsHosFnHROcxpYLlj2 PA2axYQbcSLrl7PvLHX1TOOuMn5tySDWkmkMlrkMdqsZ2Btudb rO3sXpES27XHFpIJ2X6j4KdRZcYxtwSCRstzuGrtv5LCSzOLnO dgXG9urqHgvPljfX6u6lyyYKRk5/OZxLTw/srDS1W7rWZyYywjJw2uPC9/QLp4fjn7f1Jynz83Z2n6tkzR/23830C13QQ7n1nwQfmlWXyzU8lm9MT9aJLcZXgDzcsHoHPPrPh g/NKvR5N0ysfnXLAginylT1szo207I5YXuc7ESSE6mowAlxx3bAH EkWWfq4DJPqjafIbyp9SxnJGHVa9p6Qc0Oad+w7+1av2JKj5Wy hHUubyc0UjI2SiMQO5cl88bog6UizWANc6zA4ucXX2BRW0ZjaG naBid2ttd53UqlpQwAM5oGwDADgN25SiL7bFSTC3UCDpBYbTMf 8IH+/D6SLYTSEG7QTa5sMTgL2HatP0q15kyPdzNT+YhABN7jVed4Hbs wwuClIyGjqblshBg2sZI232o3l4HhbxWRqHazGvGwgeexaBoRz lDJJKZx6Z5WPtcAA8eAB7irB1RDKYnfRvuYTuLTiY7+83q6rFY 5cfUx6ceXm6x747rtq4KbLk4+ybjqOBXVtC87rcSP0XPx6bv10 8v6JZ8YiSAk2G1ZQR8jHsuRsHvSOwa0cTYKU2mZE0ucQLAkk2A A3ns4rwqJixonkAY0XMYfzdRmqdaZ4JFsMGtNrB1ztw6pJI5Lb yanpJr/kuTRBrXkmNnHrLudIeFvzKmYukOI9Vnc885DW1Tn3Oo27Yx9m/SI6ycfBYyfJskL2CRhbrWc0nY9pPSa4YOHaFKr6+1UXZcqCuM8 2/wA3N8X/ABatEyg3at6zzP8ANzfH/wAWrQsou2rcYrCTbVCAUqZ2Ki3UEt0itbR+RJk7UacS2eP7xL7 fmaqhc9b/AKKMtWdJATjcSs7rCQDwafFUbrQSa9O0jqC8ZYrox/IVDozhHKS+I7scXs4tJPcQp8kHUvHnw9fXR1dnn5WJEQAKxtY1 ZipYepQf4Y952WHWf23rHHrb5drD0dCZJOwbT1N396zda06uo0 c+b5tgG0N9s9zcOJClGJkLMcBcbrue44AADpEnYAvP5W2mL6ip BaWx627VhZjqsB9p5sSbYaxAGwX6JMc1utZ0zZXbHTwUbD1Ofb 3YwQPF5P4VD0KSu1a7k7GTUgLQcdj3gm18bB17bzYYXVe5yZed V1L5n+0eaPcYMGt8PMlQ6LKMkLteJ7o3jY5jiw+LTdEfT1NQOL QXODXOHOBvfbgCQPIAL1bk37bf6v2XzvHpHyi3ZWz97tb1BXZ2 kvKJ/wA7N3Fo9Arpj6LZQD3ieDf1JUTKOWqSlF5542dj5Bc8GN5x8FS VNQ19ZGJJK2YtcNhfK64OA2c0YgjGww8NIlwcRvBIx296m6YvD LunKmjBbSxumPWfmYv/AGd4Diqrzqz2qcoOBqHjVaSWRtGqxhO0gbSe0klYAlcKK96Osf FI2SNxa9hDmkbQRsV25oZ2U+UGFs30xtrRlxFiALOgO3dfDEXO 3aqLXLJCCCCQRiCMCD2IPpIUk8f0UsczdwlJjkHYXtBa7jYL1j +VHa2CLtMpk/pYwX8QqOyfpHrogBy2uBukaH4dWsed5qTU6VK14sHRs7Wxgn+s lXYmLkq6mCmby08olc3EOfZkMZGwsiubu6i4uPUqgz+0hvrXGO MuEN8ScHSkHC43N7PFaplDK0s7taaR8h+0SbcBsHcvKCke/oMc74Wl3opauPK6myZTklMTZJHPEQayME3DGa17DsuV2/gcvtNDPjeyP8xXeHJoBHzrHOvcMZryOdbGw1W2x4qK+u7Ion8S P+k/++5FBXmc9Rr1VRhYiRwINtmxrh1g6p7wQcQtHylvVx5/5oGVpngHzrQdYD6xu/Abdg8ARiMaZr3XB6943j9+K3GawcyhB+Ck1BxWPa/0REh8i7UGVHwSsljNnsNx1dRBG8EXB7CozJW67S4XaHAuHW0HE L1y5LBy7/koeIbjU1+lsF74m3OvYX2WQXPknLTMpRNsWhgtrt+thmxsWu3A YWI23x6lOaKmDAsM7Nz47F1vtR7b/DfgqCyfleSnkEkLyx43jeOojYR2FWBkfTQQAKiG53vjNr/cdh4FVVg/x1u+OUHq5Ge/5F6tfPJ9HTuaPfm+YYO53Pd3NWrjTbTWw5fhqD/3WFyvpsuCIIXE+9I6w/C3b4ppiwZjDSNM9RKHvaDz3cxkQO0RMxsTsubuPXuVMZ/Z/Pr5NVl2wNPNGwvI2OcPQblgsuZyz1b9aeQutsbsY34WjALGLOr hdLpZSIcnSO6Mbzwa4+dlFRyUCyByHIOnqMwvz5GN8r3v3LtBk lriBywcTujZJKeGAAJ70G/Zu5djioGtdVQxEtbdhJc52q5xaXMDCQQTcYi/NOGKrKZ13E9ZJ8Stsyfo/qJR83RVsmO0xtp2nvfdbNQaE65/+Vp4h1zTukI7o0FVL3hoJH9CN7r7LNJ9Ar0yfoGmveSsiiw2QU zQfxuxWfpdBVGLctNVT23Pl1WnuaBbxQfOf8FkHSDWDZz3sZ5O N/JekeSGkkcs1x6o2ySk+DQPNfUmT9FeTIbatFCSMbvBlP8AWSti pcmRRi0cUbB9ljW+gQfKmT8wJ5T83R1smG3khA38T7iy2XJ+hS vfb+Thi6zPUF572xYdy+j9VLIKVyfoEn+tq4I8cRDTNce577Fb FTaDaT6+oq577Q6UMb+Fg/VWSiDU6DRVkyHo0URPW8GU/wBZK2GjyXFELRRRxgbmMaz8oClog4si5RBwQq6z90ZcvrTUtmy 4lzNjZDvLdwceo4Hs2qxlwg+RspUz4pHRyMLHtNi0ixB4HYsS3 YeB9F9WZ35h02UGWmbZ4FmStsHt7L+03sOCofO/RRW0Os5sZqIcQHxgki+A149o8wtazjQXyryMi27J2j2pltqUNZ JjiXBsDT3uH6rZqHQnXv8A8tSw47ZJXSuHcCQpq4qm6kxZMld0 Ynnt1Ta3G1leWT9BE9/na5rAdoggazu1is7S6CKIWM0tTOR78pAPc2yivnX+CvFtd0bL+ 9IweQJPkvWDI7HYCXXdfoxRSSm3Ehq+pMn6Lsmw21KKEkb3t5Q/13WxU2T44xaONjB9lrW+gQfLFBo8qJfo6Gtk6i4Ngb36wPqtky doUr3kH5LSwi310rpiPutuL9y+irLlBTOT9A89hytcyOx2QU7W/wBRsbrOU2gij+vmqp/il1R4NA9VZSINUyfosyZDbUooiRveDKf6yVsNJkyKIARxMYBsD Wtb6BSkQcWXNkRAREQEREBERAREQEREBERAREQFxZcog4sllyi AiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIi AiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIi AiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIi AiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiD//2Q==

[jjp735i]

I like the yamaha but they don't have the angle set up like Polk, It makes a huge difference having it angled up then straight out. I don't want to just lift the front, it doesn't look right. I need to have the angle up so that when I pull the big screen down the center sound comes from the screen and not underneath. I'm very anal about making sure the dialog looks like it is coming from there lips and not there feet. lol

[kelsci]

I personally would not use a that 3 way design yamahas in a 5.1 system regardless of the center channel used. I have a similar pair of KLH 900b in that design and did not like some of the phasing characteristics it created. I would much rather use a two way speaker design similar to most on the market. I could take thos Yamahas or the KLHs, disconect the internal crossovers by pulling off one wire of the tweeter and midtange and make a concocktion that would allow the speaker to be a two way design by placing a piezo tweeter on the top of the speakers. I discuss some of this on my blog.
KELSCI's ELECTRONICS AND HOME THEATER NOTATIONS: August 2010 (http://kelsci3.blogspot.com/2010_08_01_archive.html)
This does not mean that I do not like this design of speaker for it has its place. It is great as a stereo system speaker. If a receiver has a Dolby 3 setup, these speakers can be used with a D'Appolito center channel. They were also good in a Dolby Pro-Logic 4.0 set-up.
My brother recently bought a Polk center channel speaker to be used with 4 Mirage Omnis as its center channel. The speaker works well and for the 50 plus bucks he paid for it you cannot beat it. Of course you can always listen on your own set-up and see if you like what you hear.

[BadAssJazz]

I like the yamaha but they don't have the angle set up like Polk, It makes a huge difference having it angled up then straight out. I don't want to just lift the front, it doesn't look right. I need to have the angle up so that when I pull the big screen down the center sound comes from the screen and not underneath. I'm very anal about making sure the dialog looks like it is coming from there lips and not there feet. lol

Could the issue be one of timbre-matching and not simply directional audio reception/perception?

I'm not one to knock anyone's sense of pragmatism, but if your "fix" is to look for a front speaker that you can invert, well, I get a little this: :yikes:

If purchasing a third Yamaha NS-836 is not a possibility (I know it's a discontinued model) and your budget doesn't allow for upgrading both your center and mains, then all we can tell you is to try it and see. But keep that receipt handy and make sure the seller doesn't charge a restocking fee.

[Sir Terrence the Terrible]

I like the yamaha but they don't have the angle set up like Polk, It makes a huge difference having it angled up then straight out. I don't want to just lift the front, it doesn't look right. I need to have the angle up so that when I pull the big screen down the center sound comes from the screen and not underneath. I'm very anal about making sure the dialog looks like it is coming from there lips and not there feet. lol

If the speaker itself does not have a angle capable pedestal, you can make one yourself using a rubber door stop. Get a Yamaha speaker which would likely (or not) be more of a timbre match, and use the door stop in the color of the speaker to aim it upwards.

[jjp735i]

I guess I'm just going to have to try different speakers, tinbre matching is probably going to be real hard, because the 836's don't sound anything like they did originally, Like I said they now have crossovers with pot controls and realistic super tweeters installed. If this helps at all they now sound really natural, but with crisp highs, but not harsh. Almost like the pair of HPM 100's I own, but not quit as nice. They are a old pair of speakers, but they work very well with home theater and pak a good punch when needed.

Thanks for all the suggestions.