What makes a good speaker a good speaker??? [Archive] - Audio & Video Forums

PDA

View Full Version : What makes a good speaker a good speaker???



iuisthebest19
01-17-2007, 12:25 PM
I have always wanted to know what makes a high quality speaker like a klipsch speaker different than a crappy inexpensive speaker

Florian
01-17-2007, 12:34 PM
Asuming Klipsch makes good speakers. A good speaker is one that gives you a emotional response.

SlumpBuster
01-17-2007, 12:42 PM
and also one that does not create listener fatigue.

Some speakers are generally better than others because of more careful design, or better components, or better build tolerances. Speaker design is a careful balancing act between pros and cons, benefits and trade-offs. Panel vs. box, horn vs. cone, sealed vs. ported, ect. Good speakers have struck a careful balance.

basite
01-17-2007, 12:45 PM
welcome to the forum, to start with.

klipsch makes high-end speakers, they also make normal speakers, and they make budget speakers. but there is still way better than klipsch.

a good speaker is a good speaker because of so much factors,
the materials used (like cheap thin plastic vs cheap wood vs expensive, nice durable thick wood) and the materials for the drivers themselves, (like kevlar, beryllium, aluminium, rohacell, diamond, ceramic stuff) and for internal materials (like the internal wires, the crossover quality,...)
build quality also is an important factor, because you can have all the high end materials, pushed together like crap, and then you end up with very expensive garbage.
the shape of the speakers, the technology behind it,...
so many more, that's for the speakers themselves, but you still might not have good sound then,
you can invest in $$$ speakers, and ruin the sound by wrong placement, hiding your speakers, putting stuff in front of it, putting too much stuff between them, isolating them while you should be coupling them too the floor (and in reverse), ...
those are also very important,

and more important factors:
what you use to drive them with (which amps, preamps, sources, cables,...) and how they are set up,
all those things are very important,

but there is something else that is very very important,
which differs for all peoples.
The human ear, and the human taste.
you can have $$$ speakers and find that they suck, you can find it too bright, too warm, to forward, to bassy, that there's missing something...
that's why we always advice people to audition something first, and then buy it.

Hope this helped,
Greetings,
Bert.

basite
01-17-2007, 12:51 PM
Asuming Klipsch makes good speakers. A good speaker is one that gives you a emotional response.


damn, I knew I forgot something,
anyways,

to give you an example of that: when you hear music on your system, it must make you feel like the music, it must make you feel 'alive', you should almost fall in love with the sound, and it should also feel like that, music must make you feel satisfied (no, not that satisfaction, you creeps), but that doesn't necessarily mean that you'll have to turn up your volume so the whole town can hear it, of course volume is a part of the 'feeling process'.

if you play music (that you like) and you don't feel a thing, you failed.
as simple as that.


Keep them spinning,
Bert.

jrhymeammo
01-17-2007, 12:55 PM
Sony, Bose, or whatever is doesnt matter as long as you truly enjoy the music. Alot of times, it takes more so we come to this forum.......and other comical characters.

Rock789
01-17-2007, 01:11 PM
I have always wanted to know what makes a high quality speaker ... different than a crappy inexpensive speaker
How it sounds to you and only you!

SAEA501
01-17-2007, 01:17 PM
You asked about high quality. To me a high quality speaker is a linear, low distortion, accurate transducer. Adding nothing of its own when it changes electrical energy into mechanical energy.The majority of models available in todays market are not able to do this. They add something of their own character to the program in the process.

Someone mentioned listening fatigue. This is caused by higher levels of harmonic distotion. It is what makes music sound loud when it may not necessarily be measurably loud. A linear, low distortion speaker can be played at higher volumes and not be fatiguing. By the same token, it will sound very good at low, background levels as well.

All of the technical details are moot if you don't care for the sound of a truly linear speaker. Problem is, the non linear, higher distortion, sort of "in your face" type of sound comes off as more appealing initially when comparing speakers. And, unfortunately, you don't realize it until you have spent a little time listening to them at home with your equipment, in your home, on your time.

That last paragraph is written from brute experience. My experience. Some 30+ years ago I thought I knew what good sound was and I had the owner of the hi fi store where I worked raise hell with me over the speaker choice I was about to make. Did I listen? Heck no. Was he right? Absolutely. Which made it all the harder to admit to myself that I made the wrong choice.

GMichael
01-17-2007, 02:56 PM
:5: The good sound coming out of it.:5:

topspeed
01-17-2007, 03:46 PM
A good speaker is one that you like. Simple.

iuisthebest19
01-17-2007, 06:55 PM
Thank you so much
your answers helped me find what i was looking for

Rock789
01-18-2007, 05:54 AM
Thank you so much
your answers helped me find what i was looking for
what did you find?

JoeE SP9
01-18-2007, 10:38 AM
Who says Klipsch are high quality? They are high in volume for little power.:ihih:

Rock789
01-18-2007, 10:50 AM
Who says Klipsch are high quality? They are high in volume for little power.:ihih:
it depends on to what Klipsch is compared...
the reference series isn't bad at all, just priced a little high compared to other brands imo...

iuisthebest19
01-18-2007, 08:18 PM
i wasnt looking for anything specific to buy then
i just want to learn alot about speakers because music is my life and i want my life to sound good

PeruvianSkies
01-18-2007, 08:25 PM
I think that speakers can be put into 3 categories...

1. speakers that produce sound. All speakers that are working properly fit into this category.

2. speakers that produce accurate sound. Not all speakers fit into this category as some speakers add color and do not accurately reproduce the original source. Typically prices increase in this area as well as the way the speaker is constructed and the parts used.

3. speakers that produce emotion. This is referring to what Florian mentioned. A very small percentage of speakers are capable of doing so and there is usually a heavier pricetag associated with it.

emorphien
01-18-2007, 08:36 PM
I think that speakers can be put into 3 categories...

1. speakers that produce sound. All speakers that are working properly fit into this category.

2. speakers that produce accurate sound. Not all speakers fit into this category as some speakers add color and do not accurately reproduce the original source. Typically prices increase in this area as well as the way the speaker is constructed and the parts used.

3. speakers that produce emotion. This is referring to what Florian mentioned. A very small percentage of speakers are capable of doing so and there is usually a heavier pricetag associated with it.
Producing emotion is difficult to quantify simply with money. I've heard some 20k+ speakers that were very detailed and revealing, and an utter bore to listen to. I've heard sub-1k speakers that provided a great emotional response, even if they weren't the last word in accuracy.

But I think what I'm really getting at is that's the very point, speakers are subjective and which of those aspects (aside from #1) you need more of, and how they blend and match your room, electronics, music and your ears is what defines a good speaker in most practical senses.

PeruvianSkies
01-18-2007, 10:18 PM
I was simply trying to generalize the categories without getting into the dollars and cents of the matter because that turns into a huge debate. I agree that money = great sound, but at the same time it's difficult to get into the higher tier of realistic music reproduction without spending a good bit. If it were cheaper everyone could and would be an audiophile.

emorphien
01-18-2007, 10:23 PM
I don't think that it necessarily has to be very expensive for everyone though. Not saying it isn't, or couldn't be, for many of us though ;)

AudioBack
01-26-2007, 10:19 AM
I looked up a short defenition of an audiophile. Included in the defenition was that a beginner system usually costs 10,000 and up as to where veteren systems cost over 100,000. I then gladly stopped considering myself an audiophile. I love everything about sound, but I don't wanna be known as the guy that has all the expensive stuff. I wanna always be known as the guy who took not so good components to good components and making them sound great. On that note I probably have the least impressive components out of everyone on this board. I have Paradigm Mini monitor v.2 as my fronts, and matching ADP surounds and center. My sub is a car audio Cerwin Vega Vega series 12 inch in a Q-logic box powered by a 300 watt custom home sub amp. My receiver is a Denon 2801 that doesn't even do Pro Logic 2. Through experimenting with speaker placement and proper distance and level calibration on the receiver, I put something together that does bring a tear to my eye or just makes me getty. Thats the most important part. People who come over and just sit in utter shock when they hear your stuff, thats just a bonus. I agree with everyone who posted on what makes a great speaker great. They are all correct. However you can buy a truely time tested great speaker and have it sound terrible when you get home. I have a pair of Monitor 9s sitting in the closet due to this fact. My 9s used to be my mains. I never could get them to sound right. I then found that the difference is that they're front ported and not rear like the mini's. My room has a serious problem front ported speakers due to wierd room dimensions. Anyway, the bottom is if you can help it, don't buy a speaker by what you hear in the store. Most places offer demo models to try over the weekend. Hear what they sound like in your room. Room acoustics can crush a fantastic speaker. In my experience, for strangely shaped rooms where speakers don't have equal distance from side walls or one wall opens up into a kitchen area, use rear ported. Either that or go find some acoustic panneling that will turn a nice room into an ugly geek cave.

Rock789
01-26-2007, 10:25 AM
Either that or go find some acoustic panneling that will turn a nice room into an ugly geek cave.
I want one!!!

emorphien
01-26-2007, 10:45 AM
I looked up a short defenition of an audiophile. Included in the defenition was that a beginner system usually costs 10,000 and up as to where veteren systems cost over 100,000.
As far as I'm concerned that's more or less irrelevant to the point of being an "audiophile." Some people will spend that much in their lifetime, but many times more will not and that doesn't necessarily make them not audiophiles.

AudioBack
01-26-2007, 01:03 PM
Yeah, I understand the defenition is poor, but most people would not consider you an audiophile with having mid-grade equipment. It's not the way it should be, but money to a majority of people means better sound. I don't think so, but I don't wanna be confused with those people. To Rock789, I want one too!!! I had to give up alot of unorthidox methods of improving sound when I got married and the place had to look somewhat normal. :)

Rock789
01-26-2007, 03:37 PM
Yeah, I understand the defenition is poor, but most people would not consider you an audiophile with having mid-grade equipment. It's not the way it should be, but money to a majority of people means better sound. I don't think so, but I don't wanna be confused with those people. To Rock789, I want one too!!! I had to give up alot of unorthidox methods of improving sound when I got married and the place had to look somewhat normal. :)
imo, an audiophile is one who enjoys listening to music and constantly trying to increase the enjoyablity of listening to music...
does that make sence?

I'm not married yet, so have some nurd time left :cornut:

PeruvianSkies
01-27-2007, 12:10 AM
The bottom line is this....

A good speaker can disappear. If you can sit down, close your eyes, and feel the music without noticing that the music is coming from two big boxes in front of you, or in some cases a big panel or other monolithic object, than it's a great speaker. If you can sit there and listen and hear every nuance of detail and also give an approximation as to where that particular nuance is taking place within the soundfield, than it's a great speaker. Great speakers produce musicality perfectly and can do so with emotion, depth, and response.

PeruvianSkies
01-27-2007, 12:14 AM
My definition of an audiophile is this...

"Anyone who is passionate and persistant in keeping the integrity of any audible medium with the intent to preserve the artform of sound and musicality."

So what does that mean? Does it mean money? No. Does it mean a lifelong dedication to the optimal listening room? Not necessarily. An audiophile "loves" the artform of sound and sound reproduction, therefore have a desire and passion to make that a part of their life in some way, shape, or form.

Florian
01-27-2007, 02:58 AM
The bottom line is this....

A good speaker can disappear. If you can sit down, close your eyes, and feel the music without noticing that the music is coming from two big boxes in front of you, or in some cases a big panel or other monolithic object, than it's a great speaker. If you can sit there and listen and hear every nuance of detail and also give an approximation as to where that particular nuance is taking place within the soundfield, than it's a great speaker. Great speakers produce musicality perfectly and can do so with emotion, depth, and response.

In what case have you heard a panel that did not dissapear?

basite
01-27-2007, 06:11 AM
I agree that money = great sound, but at the same time it's difficult to get into the higher tier of realistic music reproduction without spending a good bit.

yes,

and no...

money will help, but it doesn't mean that cheaper speakers can't produce good sound,
take me for example, my speakers beat about every speaker in the $500 class, and can compare with $1000 speakers, and even then they'll stand strong.

and compared to dad's DM604's, I have the same imaging, if not better, soundstage is huge, bass is mighty, and they are reasonably transparent.


Greetings,
Bert.

Dusty Chalk
01-27-2007, 08:52 AM
I like the psychological effect money has -- I spent good money on it, it better sound good. Therefore, I hear "good".