I like the Marantz receivers (and I have one), but I think they're a little pricey for the sound quality you get. I've seen the 2270 go for less than $250 on eBay, though. I haven't heard the Tandberg, but I $150 might be a little high for it, too. Since we're talking about a dorm room, I guess the extra power of the Marantz isn't much of a factor and they both look great, so maybe the Tandberg is the way to go. I think you might be able to do better for $250 or get a lower price if you want. There are Sansui, Kenwood, Pioneer and even Luxman options on eBay for under $250. Craigslist might be even less.